ALLEGATIONS OF MISCONDUCT

This page explains how Jurnal Ilmiah Kesehatan Masyarakat, abbreviated as SEHATMAS, receives and assesses concerns about research integrity and publication ethics. A concern may be raised about a manuscript that is under consideration or about an article that has already been published, and it may be raised by readers, authors, reviewers, editors, institutions, or anyone else who has relevant information.

Important. Submitting a report starts an assessment. It does not by itself prove that misconduct occurred. The journal examines each report fairly, on the basis of evidence, and in proportion to the seriousness of the concern.


Procedure at a Glance

Step Stage What happens
1 Report A concern is sent to the editorial office by email, with a clear description and supporting evidence.
2 Initial assessment The office records the report, and an editor without a conflict of interest checks whether it is within the remit of the journal and has enough detail.
3 Fairness and preliminary checks The people concerned can normally respond. Evidence may be preserved, and processing may be paused as a precaution.
4 Investigation An editor without a conflict of interest leads a closer examination, and may consult the Editorial Board or independent experts.
5 Outcome A decision that is based on evidence and proportionate to the case is taken and recorded. Actions on published articles follow the Correction and Retraction policy.

1. Concerns and the Policies That Apply

The table below shows which policy guides the assessment for the most common types of concern.

Concern Applicable policy
Plagiarism, text recycling, fabricated or falsified data, manipulated images, fabricated references, and duplicate publication Plagiarism and Research Integrity Policy
Gift, guest, or ghost authorship, and authorship disputes Authorship and Contributorship
An undeclared competing interest Conflicts of Interest
Undisclosed or prohibited use of generative AI Generative AI Policies
Research without the required ethical clearance or informed consent, or a breach of the privacy of participants such as patients, respondents, and minors Publication Ethics
Manipulation of peer review, or a breach of confidentiality by an editor or a reviewer Publication Ethics and Peer Review Process

2. Submitting a Report

Please send the report by email to the editorial office at jurnal.sehatmas@gmail.com. Use the subject line Integrity Concern: [Article or Submission Identifier]. A report should include the following information.

Item Information to provide
Identification The title or the identifier of the manuscript or the article, such as the DOI.
Concern A clear and specific description of the concern.
Evidence Supporting evidence, such as documents, data, or links to the sources.
Reporter Any conflict of interest of the reporter, and any need for confidentiality.
Point Explanation
Who can be the subject of a report Reports may concern authors, reviewers, editors, and journal staff or managers.
Sensitive information Do not send sensitive personal data, for example health records or identifiable participant data, through unsecured channels. Describe the data and the editors will advise on a secure way to share them.

3. Initial Assessment

Point What is done
Recording The editorial office records every report and, where contact details are available, confirms receipt.
First review An editor without a conflict of interest decides whether the concern is within the remit of the journal, whether it contains enough detail, and whether clarification from the reporter is needed.
Substance first Reports are judged on their substance, and not on the status of the reporter.
Anonymous reports An anonymous report can be assessed when it is specific and can be verified.
Unsupported reports A report without support may be closed. It can be reconsidered if new evidence appears.

4. Fairness, Preliminary Checks, and Referral

Topic What it means
Right to respond The people who are the subject of a specific concern can normally respond, with safeguards that protect the process and the people involved.
Preliminary checks The journal may carry out limited checks before it contacts the parties, for example to preserve evidence or to protect research participants.
Pausing Editorial processing of the manuscript or the article concerned may be paused while a credible concern is assessed. This is a precaution and not a finding of misconduct.
Referral A matter that is beyond the authority of the journal may be referred to the institution of the authors, the funder, the ethics committee that approved the study, or another competent body.

5. Investigation and Outcomes

Point What is done
Who leads An editor without a conflict of interest leads any case that needs a closer examination. The editor may consult members of the Editorial Board or independent experts.
Explanations Authors and other people concerned are asked to explain their actions and, where relevant, to provide data, documents, or permissions.
Decision Decisions are based on evidence and are proportionate to the seriousness of the case.
Records The journal keeps a confidential record of the report and of the steps that were taken.

5.1 Possible Outcomes

Stage Possible outcomes
Before publication A request for clarification, corrected citations, or proper attribution; a request to rewrite or revise the manuscript; a request for data, permissions, or documents; a pause in the editorial evaluation; and rejection of the manuscript when serious misconduct is established.
After publication A correction or corrigendum; an expression of concern while an investigation is unresolved; retraction when the record is substantially unreliable or serious misconduct is proven; notification of the institutions or authorities concerned; and other proportionate steps to protect the scholarly record.

Actions on published articles follow the Correction and Retraction policy. Scholarly comments on a published article may be raised through the Post Publication Discussion page.

6. Confidentiality and Protection of Reporters

Principle How it is applied
Confidential handling Reports are handled confidentially, and information is shared only with the people who need it to assess the concern.
Identity of the reporter The identity of a person who reports a concern in good faith is kept confidential as far as possible.
No retaliation The journal does not accept retaliation against a person who reports a concern in good faith.
False reports A report that is knowingly false or malicious is itself a breach of publication ethics.

Related Policies and Enquiries

Topic Page
Ethical principles of the journal Publication Ethics
Originality and research integrity Plagiarism and Research Integrity Policy
Corrections, expressions of concern, and retractions Correction and Retraction
Other related policies Conflicts of Interest, Generative AI Policies, and Authorship and Contributorship

For questions about this procedure, please contact the editorial office at jurnal.sehatmas@gmail.com.